Gemini 4 Carbon Reaches AI Pro Users in AI Mode, but Stays Out of All 30 EEA Countries
Google's Rajan Patel says Gemini 4 Carbon appearing in AI Mode for AI Pro subscribers is not a bug, though Google's help page still lists it for Ultra only. Our check of Google's country lists finds Carbon in AI Mode missing from all 30 EEA countries, despite both paid plans being sold there.

Ras Al Khaimah, United Arab Emirates, .
Gemini 4 Carbon, the frontier model Google launched for AI Ultra subscribers on 10 November, is now showing up in AI Mode for Google AI Pro subscribers too. Rajan Patel, Google's VP of Engineering for Search, replied "Not a bug" on 15 November to a user who reported the model appearing for Pro subscribers, according to Search Engine Roundtable. Separately, the AI Mode header stopped naming the selected Gemini model, which Patel said was intended. Our check of Google's own pages on 16 November found two gaps the coverage so far has missed: Google's help page still lists Carbon in AI Mode for Ultra subscribers only, and its country list leaves out all 27 EU member states, plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway, even though Google sells both paid plans there.
What changed
- Carbon for Pro subscribers. Google's Carbon announcement on 10 November said the model was rolling out to all Google AI Ultra subscribers in Google Antigravity, the Gemini app and AI Mode in Search. Pro was not mentioned. Gagan Ghotra posted on 12 November that Google seemed to be rolling Carbon out in AI Mode for Pro subscribers, and Patel answered on 15 November that this was not a bug.
- No model name in the header. Ghotra also shared a screenshot of the AI Mode header naming the Gemini model in use. That label has gone, and the header now reads only "AI Mode". Patel described the removal as intended and said Google is thinking about how to bring back an indicator for the selected model.
- Nothing changed for free users. Free users keep Gemini 4 Hydrogen, which became the default model in Search on 12 November.
The Gemini app is a different story. In its coverage of the 10 November launch, 9to5Google reported that Carbon arrived in the app for Ultra subscribers while Pro kept Argon. Nothing we found says that has changed, so Pro subscribers may now have Carbon in Search before they have it in the app.
Google's own pages have not caught up
We read the three Google pages that describe Carbon access on 16 November (UTC). None of them mentions Carbon for Pro subscribers in Search.
| Google page | What it says about Carbon | Mentions Pro access in AI Mode? |
|---|---|---|
| Keyword blog launch post, 10 November | Rolling out to all Google AI Ultra subscribers in Antigravity, the Gemini app and AI Mode | No |
| AI Mode help page | Available to users in listed countries who are Google AI Ultra subscribers aged 18 and above, with daily usage limits | No |
| Google AI plans page | Ultra's Google Search benefits include "highest access" to Carbon; Pro's Search benefits list Nano Banana and agentic capabilities | No |
Source: SaaS Link Building review of Google's pages, 16 November 2026 (UTC).
The help page also says that users can pick Carbon from the menu in the "Ask anything" bar, and that Hydrogen is meant for fast, all-round help on most questions. Until Google updates these pages, the only on-record confirmation that Pro accounts should see Carbon is Patel's reply.
Our check: where Carbon in AI Mode is available
The AI Mode help page publishes two country lists: one for AI Mode itself and one for Carbon in AI Mode. We compared them with each other and with Google's list of markets where Google AI Pro and Ultra are sold.
| Region (as Google groups it) | AI Mode countries and territories | Where Pro and Ultra are sold | Carbon in AI Mode | Paid markets without Carbon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Americas | 52 | 34 | 32 | 2 |
| Asia-Pacific | 57 | 31 | 27 | 4 |
| Europe, the Middle East and Africa | 139 | 96 | 63 | 33 |
| Total | 248 | 161 | 122 | 39 |
Source: SaaS Link Building comparison of Google Search Help (AI Mode and Carbon country lists) and Google Gemini Help (Pro and Ultra markets), collected 16 November 2026 (UTC). See Methodology.
Three things stand out:
- Every EEA country is missing. None of the 27 EU member states is on the Carbon list, and neither are Iceland, Liechtenstein or Norway. All 30 are on the AI Mode list and on the list of markets where Pro and Ultra are sold.
- The rest of the gap is small and specific. The other nine paid markets without Carbon are Hong Kong, Macao, Türkiye, French Polynesia, Caribbean Netherlands and four French overseas departments (Guadeloupe, Martinique, Mayotte and Réunion).
- Europe outside the EEA is mostly in. The United Kingdom, Switzerland, Ukraine, Serbia, Monaco and San Marino are on the Carbon list. Every country on the Carbon list is also a market where Pro and Ultra are sold.
Google has not said why the EEA is excluded. It is our speculation, not a Google statement, that the pattern fits a regulatory hold. It matches the footprint of the EU's Digital Markets Act, which has already shaped Google's results pages in the region, as our 69-SERP test after the EU fine showed. Hong Kong, Macao and Türkiye fall outside that explanation.
Why the missing model label matters
For anyone tracking AI Mode visibility, the header label was the simplest way to record which model produced an answer. Paying users can now switch between Argon, Carbon and Hydrogen, and a screenshot no longer shows which one was used. Google says each model behaves differently: its Carbon post describes a model that uses more tokens than Argon to "reason deeply", while Hydrogen is pitched as the fast default. Our Hydrogen test found that answers to detailed multi-part queries cited 24 non-Google sources against 14 for short ones, so model and query style both shape which sites get cited.
This sits alongside other changes to the AI Mode interface. Google has been testing how prominently it shows AI Mode at all, a test we measured in our check of the AI Mode tab on mobile results.
What this means for SEO teams
- Log the model by hand. If your team checks AI Mode answers on a paid account, record the model picked in the "Ask anything" menu next to every capture, since the header no longer shows it.
- Do not mix tiers in one dataset. A free account (Hydrogen) and a Pro or Ultra account (with Argon or Carbon selectable) can see different answers to the same query. Keep them apart in reporting.
- Segment European checks. If you track AI Mode in EU markets, Carbon is not on Google's list there. Answers seen from Germany or France should not be compared with Carbon answers from the US or UK.
- Treat Carbon reach as small. Carbon in AI Mode needs a paid plan, an account holder aged 18 or over and a supported country, and it has daily limits. Hydrogen remains what most searchers see.
- Watch the help page. When Google adds Pro to the Carbon section or brings back a model indicator, the AI Mode help page, which already has a Carbon section, is the most likely place for it to appear.
Methodology
On 16 November 2026 (UTC) we downloaded the English version of Google's AI Mode help page and parsed its two country lists: "AI Mode availability" (248 entries) and "Gemini 4 Carbon in AI Mode Availability" (122 entries). We then downloaded the Gemini Help page section "Where Google AI Pro & Google AI Ultra are available" (161 entries) and matched names across pages, normalising four spelling differences (Czech Republic and Czechia, Cabo Verde and Cape Verde, Macau and Macao, US Virgin Islands and U.S. Virgin Islands). Regions follow the AI Mode list's own grouping. We counted the EU as its 27 member states and the EEA as those plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway. Posting dates for the X posts by Gagan Ghotra and Rajan Patel come from the timestamps encoded in the post IDs that Search Engine Roundtable cited. We did not test Carbon on a Pro account ourselves.
Conclusion
Carbon's move to Pro subscribers in AI Mode is real according to a Google engineering lead, but it is not yet documented anywhere on Google's own pages, and the model is still unavailable in every EEA country where Google sells its paid plans. With the model name gone from the AI Mode header, the burden of recording which model produced an answer now falls on whoever is doing the tracking.
For SEO teams, the practical effect is narrow: most searchers still get Hydrogen. The more lasting change is that AI Mode results now depend on tier, model choice and country, and none of those shows on screen.
Questions and answers
Can Google AI Pro subscribers use Gemini 4 Carbon in AI Mode?
Users reported Carbon appearing in AI Mode on Pro accounts from 12 November 2026, and Google's Rajan Patel replied on 15 November that this was not a bug. Google's AI Mode help page and its AI plans page still list Carbon in Search for Ultra subscribers only.
Why doesn't the AI Mode header show the Gemini model any more?
Google removed the model name from the AI Mode header. Rajan Patel said the change was intended and that Google is thinking through how to bring back an indicator for the selected model.
Is Gemini 4 Carbon in AI Mode available in the EU?
No. Google's list of countries with Gemini 4 Carbon in AI Mode, checked on 16 November 2026, includes none of the 27 EU member states and none of Iceland, Liechtenstein or Norway, although AI Mode and the Google AI Pro and Ultra plans are available in all of them. Google has not explained why.
Which Gemini model do free users get in AI Mode?
Google made Gemini 4 Hydrogen the model in Google Search for all users on 12 November 2026. Google's help page describes Hydrogen as helpful for fast, all-round assistance on most questions.
More releases
-
Updates
Search Console API Adds Branded, Multimodal and Multi-Country Filters, 361 Days After UI
Google's Search Analytics API can now return branded and non-branded data, multimodal search performance from Lens and Circle to Search, and multi-country or multi-device filters in one request. The branded filter reached the API 361 days after its announcement, and Google's API specification caps each filter list at 1,000 values.
-
Industry news
Google Loses Second Round to SerpApi: Court Sided Against It on 12 of 15 Points
A federal judge dismissed Google's amended DMCA complaint against SerpApi on 9 November 2026, the second dismissal in the scraping case. Our reading of the 19-page order finds the court sided with SerpApi on 12 of 15 contested points. Google has until 30 November to refile or the case ends with prejudice.
-
Studies
Does Google Pause Updates for the Holidays? One Ran on 51% of Peak-Season Days
Google says it tries to avoid ranking updates from late November to mid-December. Its own Search Status Dashboard shows a notable update rolling out on 53 of 104 days in that window from 2022 to 2025, against 30% of days across the year. The one gap since 2022: no launches in late November.
Tell us the site and the goals.
Rankings in Google and visibility in AI answers, from one monthly plan. One call is enough to say which one fits. Email works just as well.